Bark Beetle Detection

Aerial detection survey vs satellite monitoring for bark beetle outbreaks

A small fixed-wing aircraft in flight over a green forest canopy.

Every region office runs this comparison eventually: stick with the aerial detection survey you've flown for years, or start layering in satellite-based monitoring between flights. ADS and satellite imagery don't solve the same problem. Knowing which gap each one fills keeps you from re-flying country you already have data on, or trusting a pixel count more than it deserves.

What ADS actually gives you

Aerial detection survey is still the backbone of most state and provincial forest health programs, and for good reason. A trained observer in a fixed-wing aircraft or helicopter sketch-maps mortality polygons in near real time, calling top-kill, red-attack crowns, and fade by eye against a GPS track. That's a skill set built over seasons, and it catches things a sensor alone won't, like an observer noting that a patch reads as beetle but the crown structure says blowdown instead.

The limits show up on the calendar, not in the methodology. ADS flies in windows: good visibility, acceptable smoke, aircraft and observer availability, and often a single pass per management unit per year, sometimes two if the budget and the infestation both justify it. Smoke from an active fire season can scrub a flight entirely. A wet spring can push the survey past the point where red-attack has already started fading toward grey, which means the polygon you get back is already behind the stand's actual stage. And because it's observer-based, calibration varies some from crew to crew and year to year, which agencies manage through training but can't fully remove.

None of that makes ADS wrong. It makes it a snapshot, and a snapshot taken once a year can't tell you whether a stand you flagged in July is still red-attack in September or has already gone grey and lost most of its salvage value.

Where satellite monitoring fits, and where it doesn't

Satellite-based multispectral monitoring doesn't replace an observer's judgment call on the ground or in the air. What it does is fill the months between flights with a read that doesn't depend on an aircraft being available, a sky being clear enough to fly, or a crew having bandwidth that week. It's also limited by cloud cover and revisit timing, so it's not a substitute for ground truth either. Combine the two and you get something closer to a continuous record: ADS for the calibrated annual pass, satellite for tracking how fast a given infestation is moving through its stages in between.

That combination matters most for the decision ADS alone wasn't built to support quickly: stage-by-stand prioritization for salvage. A sketch map tells you a stand is infested. It doesn't tell you, three months later, whether that stand is still worth a salvage crew's time or has already crossed into grey-attack, where the merchantable value has dropped and the window has closed. That's the specific gap a monthly scored layer tracking infestation stage is built around, one that tracks the red-attack to grey-attack progression across your forest health monitoring area so the stage register doesn't go stale between flight seasons.

A few things to check before you lean on either method

Ask what resolution the imagery actually supports for your stand sizes, not just what the sensor spec sheet claims. Ask how revisit cadence lines up with your fire season and cloud patterns, because a monthly product that gets clouded out for two consecutive months isn't monthly where it counts. And keep your ADS program's sketch-mapping standards as the calibration reference either way. Satellite monitoring is a supplement to that institutional knowledge, not a reason to stop flying.

If your program is trying to turn a once-a-year ADS pass into a stage-by-stand register you can act on between flights, Bark Beetle Detection is worth a look.

Start a project

Back to the blog